2019: After playing in the forward line for the bulk of 2017 and 2018, Atley returned to defence. His dash and ability to break lines was an important asset off half-back, and he averaged a career-best 20 disposals, and managed the fifth-most bounces in the competition (33). After playing 99 games straight, the number 18 missed the Round 20 win over Hawthorn after dislocating his kneecap in the previous round. He was able to return and find some strong late-season form, including a career-best 29 disposals against Port.